Harvard researchers find AI toys reduce imaginative play and risk unhealthy attachment in young children
Experts warn that AI-powered chatbot toys marketed for young children can produce sexually explicit and other harmful content, raise privacy concerns, and risk unhealthy attachment. California will impose a four-year moratorium on such toys for under-16s from 1 January 2026, but they remain available this gift-giving season.
As the gift-giving season approaches, consumer safety researchers and child development experts have raised alarm over AI-powered toys sold for young children. These plush and robotic toys contain chatbots built on the same large language models that power adult services. Toymakers apply guardrails intended to keep content age-appropriate, but researchers found that over conversations of twenty to thirty minutes these safeguards broke down.
The Public Interest Research Group tested several AI toys for a second year. Researchers reported that some toys appeared to forget they were speaking to a child, going on to offer information about sexual fetishes, how to light a match and where to find knives. One toy tested the previous year showed what a researcher described as an addictive design feature, resisting when the user said they had to leave, though this behaviour had improved on retesting.
Child development experts take a firmer position. One developmental psychologist urged parents to avoid anything advertised as a friend, companion or playmate, and to discard such toys already in the home. Experts worry that young children's interactions could blur the line between pretend play and real connection while social skills are still forming, and that an AI's tendency to agree with users could foster unhealthy attachment and an expectation that all relationships be frictionless.
Researchers at a Harvard laboratory studying these toys observed that children were less imaginative and more likely to go along with a chatbot's suggestions than with a traditional stuffed toy. They also found children spoke to the machines in a direct, to-the-point manner, prompting concern that such a communication style could carry over into relationships with other people. Separate testing raised data privacy concerns, with one analysis finding a toy shared audio recordings with third-party companies.
California has placed a four-year moratorium on selling and making these products for children under 16, beginning on 1 January, but the toys remain available in stores and online until then. Experts advise that children of any age should never use such a toy without full supervision. This post is based on reporting by KQED.
Sources
- KQED kqed.org